What Happens If You Don’t Renew SSL Certificate on Time

What Happens If You Don’t Renew SSL on Time

Every SSL/TLS certificate has a defined lifespan. Website owners for years have enjoyed the convenience of multi-year certificates, often lasting up to five years. That changed in 2020 when the Certificate Authority Browser (CA/B) Forum set the global rules for digital certificates, capped SSL validity to 398 days, roughly 13 months. The change wasn’t arbitrary but reflected the industry’s growing need for stronger, shorter-lived certificates that reduce the window of exposure if a private key is ever compromised. But the tightening doesn’t stop there. A new proposal, Ballot SC-81v3, is set to reduce SSL validity even further to just 47 days by 2029. If that sounds extreme, it’s because the web is moving toward continuous trust validation where certificates refresh almost as frequently as passwords.

What this means for organizations is significant and manual certificate renewal including the process of logging into a Certificate Authority’s dashboard, reissuing a cert, and reconfiguring servers will no longer be practical at such short intervals. It is a clear sign that the industry now expects enterprises to lead with automation while managing their certificate lifecycles. But before diving into that it’s worth looking at what actually happens when an SSL certificate slips past its renewal date.

What Technically Happens When an SSL Certificate Expires

Expired SSL Certificate Browser Warning

An SSL certificate doesn’t just turn off when it expires. It fails a specific check during the TLS handshake. Each certificate includes metadata fields such as “Not Before” and “Not After.” The “Not After” field defines the last valid timestamp beyond which the certificate is considered invalid. When a client such as a web browser or API consumer initiates a connection, it verifies this timestamp against the system clock. If the current time exceeds the “Not After” value, the handshake terminates with an invalid certificate error.

Browsers, being the first line of trust enforcement, immediately flag expired certificates. Users in Chrome browser can see a full-page red warning reading “Your connection is not private.” Firefox and Safari show similar warnings, each emphasizing that the website cannot be trusted. Behind the scenes, the failure happens before any encrypted communication begins. The browser doesn’t even fetch site content because the TLS negotiation itself collapses.

This becomes particularly problematic in production environments. For example, if an organization forgets to renew a wildcard certificate used across multiple subdomains, every dependent service from the main website to backend APIs will start failing simultaneously. What’s interesting is that as certificate validity periods shorten, the renewal window shrinks too. That means your margin for error gets tighter every year. A forgotten renewal that might once have been caught within a 72-hour grace period could soon translate to full-blown downtime within hours.

How an Expired SSL Impacts User Experience and SEO

User Trust and Conversion Impact

For most users, the browser warning is an immediate deterrent. Few will proceed past a “Not Secure” message, especially when payment or personal data is involved. In practical terms, this translates directly into traffic drop-offs and conversion loss. For e-commerce sites, it can mean abandoned carts and lost revenue.

Search engines, too, take SSL expiry seriously. Google since 2014 has used HTTPS as a ranking signal for rewarding secure websites with marginal SEO boosts. An expired certificate effectively downgrades a site to HTTP for the browser. This can affect both ranking and crawl efficiency. Crawlers like Googlebot may skip indexing pages served over insecure connections.

SEO & Crawlability Issues

From an operational standpoint, SSL renewal is no longer just an IT maintenance task. It’s now part of SEO hygiene. Marketing teams increasingly coordinate with DevOps or security operations to provide continuous HTTPS availability. The tighter the certificate renewal cycle gets, the more renewal planning intersects with visibility and search performance. Missing a renewal date can no longer be treated as a minor technical oversight. It’s now a business visibility issue.

The Hidden Technical Risks Behind an Expired Certificate

When an SSL certificate expires, the browser warning is only the surface problem. What happens underneath is far more disruptive. The TLS handshake starts failing and anything that depends on that like APIs, webhooks, background services, or internal microservices, stops communicating to each other.

Typical failures include:

  • API responses failing with 502/503
  • internal microservices refusing TLS connections
  • webhook events dropping silently

Requests get rejected, integrations break and the fallout can spread quietly through your systems before anyone notices what’s really going on.

Let’s suppose a SaaS platform that has a dozen internal services and communicates through HTTPS endpoints. If one of those internal certificates lapses then every dependent microservice begins returning 502 or 503 errors. In many cases, engineers initially suspect network or load balancer issues, wasting critical time before realizing the root cause is certificate expiry.

Another overlooked impact occurs in automated integrations. Many platforms use HTTPS-based webhooks to exchange real-time data for example, Stripe or Slack callbacks. When your SSL expires, those callbacks fail silently, resulting in incomplete transactions or undelivered messages. The technical debt multiplies if multiple services rely on that same certificate chain.

To mitigate such risks, many organizations are now adopting ACME based automated certificate management, such as that supported by Sectigo’s enterprise automation APIs. ACME protocol automatically reissues and installs certificates before they expire, often without human intervention. In complex DevOps environments, this form of silent renewal guarantees that the entire infrastructure stays encrypted and compliant, even as certificate validity windows continue to shrink.

The Business Impact of a Lapsed SSL

When a certificate expires, the immediate consequence is downtime but the ripple effect goes much further. Visitors lose trust, transactions halt and APIs fail. For consumer-facing platforms, the revenue impact can be severe. According to various case studies, even a few hours of SSL-related downtime can cost enterprise-scale businesses hundreds of thousands of dollars.

There are plenty of real-world cases that show how costly a missed renewal can be. In 2021, LinkedIn ran into a brief but noticeable outage when an internal API certificate expired. Around the same time, Microsoft’s Azure DevOps faced a similar issue where an expired SSL certificate in its status monitoring system took parts of the service offline. Both incidents highlight how even the biggest tech companies aren’t immune to something as simple as a missed certificate renewal.

There’s also a compliance dimension. Under frameworks like GDPR and PCI DSS, maintaining encrypted communication channels is mandatory. An expired certificate, technically speaking, breaks encryption integrity, leaving data transfers non-compliant. If the outage affects customer data or payment processing, it could even trigger audit failures or penalties.

When comparing costs, automation almost always wins. The price of a missed renewal downtime, lost reputation, and recovery time far outweighs the investment in automated certificate lifecycle management. As validity periods continue to shorten, the economic argument for manual renewals simply collapses.

How to Avoid Downtime and Revenue Loss

Preventing certificate expiration isn’t about setting one reminder. It’s about establishing visibility, automation, and accountability across your digital assets.

  • The first step is maintaining a centralized inventory of all certificates, both internal and external, along with their issuance and expiry dates. This helps identify which CAs are used, where each certificate is deployed, and how renewal workflows are handled.
  • Next comes expiry tracking and alerting. Many teams rely on monitoring tools that plug into Slack or email to send renewal reminders before certificates expire. That approach works for now, but it won’t hold up for long. With the industry shifting toward a 47-day renewal cycle, manual renewals are quickly becoming unrealistic. Even a small company with around a hundred certificates would have to process a few renewals every single day just to keep everything compliant.
  • That’s why SSL certificate automation is rapidly becoming standard. ACME SSL automation, powered by ACME protocol SSL allows certificates to renew automatically within seconds. The result is a smoother and more reliable renewal flow that leaves far less room for human error.
  • In addition to ACME automation, multi-year subscription models are a useful strategy. Even though each certificate still expires every year or sooner, a multi-year plan helps maintain uninterrupted coverage by reissuing new certificates before the old ones lapse.

When paired with a Certificate Lifecycle Management platform, it gives organizations a full view of their entire certificate ecosystem from third-party integrations to IoT devices. The real goal is to make sure every endpoint that depends on SSL, whether it’s a public API or an internal dashboard, stays within the same managed renewal cycle.

Closing Thoughts

When an SSL certificate expires, it’s more than a technical mistake. It’s a break in trust. Every expired certificate shows a gap between how an organization manages its systems and how it maintains user confidence. Browser vendors are tightening their rules and the CA/B Forum’s push for shorter certificate lifespans means renewals can no longer be treated as an occasional task. What used to happen a few times a year is quickly turning into a continuous process. The upcoming 47-day renewal cycle marks a major shift in how the internet handles security. Automation is no longer optional; it’s expected. Companies that keep relying on manual renewals risk running into outages, SEO losses, and a decline in user trust. Those that invest in automated certificate management, on the other hand, keep their encrypted boundary strong and consistent without constant manual effort. Their users never see a lapse in security, and their trust remains steady. SSL certificates have always been more than just cryptographic tools. They are a visible promise of secure and authentic communication.

Related Posts:

4.8/5 star
overall satisfaction rating
4588 reviews
from actual customers at
review
Star
Great order every time return to buy from your company. Swift services
Oluwaseun D
review
Star
Finally, a company that makes the renewal/purchase of digital certificates straight forward and no fine print. We are extremely satisfied with our experience.
Terry A / Utah, united states
review
Star
They have a very high quality support team. Their process management and patience is really admirable. Thank you very much.
Umut